Lumber Jack Competition Blend is the best all-around BBQ pellet for most pellet grill owners: an even maple, hickory, and cherry mix that works on ribs, pork, chicken, and most beef. If you smoke a lot of brisket, Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend adds oak to the mix, and if you want maximum smoke, Lumber Jack 100% Hickory is the straight option.
Bag sizes are shifting. Traeger’s current Amazon listing for its Signature Blend is an 18 lb bag, not the older 20 lb size, so a price-per-bag comparison against other brands no longer lines up. We compared wood species, bag size, and manufacturer claims, and checked every pick against live Amazon listings. If you are still choosing a grill, start with our pellet grill roundup or the Traeger vs Pit Boss comparison.
| Spec | Lumber Jack Competition Blend Maple-Hickory-Cherry BBQ Grilling Pellets, 20 lb 9.2/10 | Traeger Signature Blend Wood Pellets for Pellet Grills & Smokers, 18 lb 8.9/10 | Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend Wood Pellets for Smoker, Grill & BBQ, 20 lb 9/10 | Camp Chef Competition Blend BBQ Pellets, 20 lb 8.8/10 | Pit Boss 40-Pound Bag of 100% Natural Hardwood Competition Blend BBQ Grilling Pellets 8.6/10 | Lumber Jack 100% Hickory BBQ Grilling Pellets, 20 lb 8.7/10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| wood | Maple, hickory, cherry | Hickory, maple, cherry | Oak, hickory, maple, cherry | Maple, hickory, cherry | Hickory, apple, maple, oak | 100% hickory |
| bag_size | 20 lb | 18 lb | 20 lb | 20 lb | 40 lb | 20 lb |
| blend_method | Fiber blended before pelleting | — | — | — | — | — |
| best_for | Pork, ribs, poultry, all-purpose | Traeger grills, everyday cooking | — | Pork and poultry | Frequent smokers | Ribs, pork shoulder, bacon |
| flavor | Medium, slightly sweet | — | — | — | Balanced, with fruitwood sweetness | Strong, traditional BBQ |
| Rating | 9.2/10 | 8.9/10 | 9/10 | 8.8/10 | 8.6/10 | 8.7/10 |
Prices change daily — tap Check Price for the current Amazon price.
Prices change daily — tap Check Price for the current Amazon price.
Quick Picks
- Best Overall: Lumber Jack Competition Blend. Maple, hickory, and cherry blended before pelleting.
- Best for Brisket and Beef: Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend. Oak, hickory, maple, and cherry in one bag.
- Best for Traeger Owners: Traeger Signature Blend. Matched to the brand’s grills, in an 18 lb bag.
- Best Bulk Bag: Pit Boss Competition Blend. A 40 lb bag for frequent smokers.
- Strongest Smoke: Lumber Jack 100% Hickory. Best for ribs and pulled pork.
What to Know Before Buying BBQ Wood Pellets
Blend or single wood?
A blend gives you one bag that handles most cooks. A single wood gives you control. Hickory delivers traditional BBQ flavor with bacon-like undertones and suits ribs and pork. Oak is the usual choice for brisket and beef. Cherry and apple are milder and sweeter and sit better on chicken, pork loin, and fish.
Most competition blends combine hickory, maple, and cherry so the smoke is strong enough for pork but not so harsh that it ruins poultry. If you cook a mix of meats, start with a blend and add a single-wood bag later for specific cooks.
Pure hardwood, no fillers
Look for pellets listed as 100% hardwood with no binders, flavor oils, or fillers. Some brands bake flavor in with additives; the better ones rely on the wood itself. Bear Mountain lists no flavorings, fillers, or additives. Pit Boss says its pellets use no artificial flavors, spray scents, glues, or chemicals. Traeger lists no binders and low ash. Camp Chef lists kiln-dried, 100% pure hardwood.
Bag size and cost per pound
Four of the six picks come in 20 lb bags, Traeger comes in 18 lb, and the Pit Boss pick is 40 lb. Divide the bag price by pounds before comparing. A 40 lb bag cuts your trips and usually lowers the per-pound cost, but it only pays off if you smoke often and can store it dry.
Do pellet brands matter for your grill?
Any food-grade hardwood pellet fits any pellet grill that takes standard pellets. Traeger and Pit Boss both make pellets for their own grills, but neither is required. Pellets that are too damp or dusty cause the same problems in any grill: poor temperature control, auger jams, and heavy ash. Bear Mountain also lists its pellets as usable in gas, charcoal, and electric grills.
Storage
Pellets swell and crumble when damp. Keep them in a sealed bin, not an open bag, and store them off the garage floor. If a bag arrives dusty, sift the dust out before it goes in the hopper. Never leave pellets in the hopper during a rainy week, and empty it before winter storage.
How we ranked these picks
We ranked on wood species, listed ingredients and manufacturer claims, bag size, versatility across meats, and how widely each fits different grills. We did not compare smoke flavor ourselves. The flavor notes come from the wood types and the manufacturer descriptions. All six were in stock on Amazon when we checked.
Seasonal buying tips
Fall is brisket and pork-shoulder season, and holiday weekends use more pellets than usual. Buy ahead of a big cook so you are not driving to a store with an empty hopper. Cold weather also makes a grill burn more fuel to hold temperature, so plan for extra pellets once temperatures drop.
Which Wood for Which Meat
- Brisket and beef: oak-based blends such as Bear Mountain or Pit Boss Competition.
- Ribs and pork shoulder: hickory, either straight or in a competition blend.
- Chicken and turkey: cherry- or apple-heavy blends; avoid straight hickory.
- Fish and vegetables: fruitwood blends, used lightly.
- Mixed cookouts: Lumber Jack or Camp Chef Competition Blend.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Buying the cheapest bag without checking the ingredients. Fillers and binders make more ash and less flavor.
- Comparing bag prices without comparing bag weights. An 18 lb bag is not a 20 lb bag.
- Using straight hickory on everything. It overpowers poultry and fish.
- Leaving pellets open in a damp garage.
- Switching brands mid-cook. If you change pellets, run the auger until the old ones are cleared first.
Detailed Reviews
1. Lumber Jack Competition Blend Maple-Hickory-Cherry BBQ Grilling Pellets


Lumber Jack Competition Blend Maple-Hickory-Cherry BBQ Grilling Pellets, 20 lb
The Lumber Jack Competition Blend is one-third maple, one-third hickory, and one-third cherry, and the fiber is blended before it is pelleted. That means every pellet contains the full recipe rather than a mix of separate single-wood pellets. In a hopper, that keeps smoke flavor steady from the first pellet to the last.
This is the safest pick if you cook a mix of meats. The hickory carries pork and ribs, the cherry softens the smoke on poultry, and the maple rounds it out. It is milder than straight hickory, so beef lovers may want oak instead.
2. Traeger Signature Blend Wood Pellets


Traeger Signature Blend Wood Pellets for Pellet Grills & Smokers, 18 lb
The Traeger Signature Blend is hickory, maple, and cherry in an 18 lb bag, listed as 100% natural hardwood with no binders and low ash, made in the USA. It is the pellet Traeger designs its grills around, which is why owners tend to stick with it.
The recipe is the same as the Lumber Jack and Camp Chef blends, so you are paying for the brand. Do the per-pound math: the smaller bag makes it look cheaper than it is. Traeger owners who want one less variable will like it; everyone else can save money on a competitor.
3. Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend Wood Pellets


Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend Wood Pellets for Smoker, Grill & BBQ, 20 lb
Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend uses oak, hickory, maple, and cherry in a 20 lb bag. The listing states no flavorings, fillers, or additives, and a low moisture content for clean burning.
The oak gives it more of a beef-friendly backbone than the three-wood competition blends, which makes it the best blended pellet here for brisket and steaks. It still handles pork and chicken. If you want a single bag for a family barbecue where the menu changes weekly, this is the one.
4. Camp Chef Competition Blend BBQ Pellets


The Camp Chef Competition Blend is kiln-dried, 100% hardwood pellets in a maple, hickory, and cherry mix, in a 20 lb bag. The recipe matches Lumber Jack and Traeger, so the buying decision comes down to price per pound and availability.
It is a good second bag to keep around. Use it when your usual pellet is out of stock, or to stretch a bag of straight hickory by mixing the two.
5. Pit Boss 100% Natural Hardwood Competition Blend, 40 lb


Pit Boss 40-Pound Bag of 100% Natural Hardwood Competition Blend BBQ Grilling Pellets
The Pit Boss Competition Blend comes in a 40 lb bag and combines hickory, apple, maple, and oak. Pit Boss states it uses no artificial flavors, spray scents, glues, or chemicals. The apple adds a sweeter fruitwood note that the three-wood blends lack, and the oak helps with beef.
Heavy users should look here first. A 40 lb bag is two refills of a typical 20 lb bag, and it fits any pellet grill. The only real drawback is storage: once you open a bag this size, put the pellets in a sealed bin.
6. Lumber Jack 100% Hickory BBQ Grilling Pellets


Lumber Jack 100% Hickory BBQ Grilling Pellets, 20 lb
Lumber Jack 100% Hickory is the single-wood pick: 20 lb of straight hickory for ribs, pork shoulder, and bacon. It produces the strongest traditional BBQ flavor of the six.
Most people will not run this exclusively. Use it when you want a bold smoke on pork, or add a few handfuls to a milder blend to boost the smoke. Avoid it for poultry and fish, where straight hickory can taste harsh.
Related Articles
- Best Pellet Grills in 2026
- Is a Pellet Grill Worth It?
- Traeger vs Pit Boss Pellet Grills
- Best Grill Meat Thermometers
- Best Smokers for Beginners
FAQ
What are the best wood pellets for smoking brisket?
Oak-based pellets are the usual choice for brisket and beef. Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend and the Pit Boss Competition Blend both include oak. Hickory also works, either blended or mixed into an oak blend.
Can I use any brand of pellets in my pellet grill?
Yes. Standard food-grade hardwood pellets fit any pellet grill. Traeger and Pit Boss make pellets for their own grills, but you can use Lumber Jack, Camp Chef, or Bear Mountain in them. Check your grill manual for any pellet-size guidance.
Are competition blend pellets different from other pellets?
A competition blend is usually a mix of maple, hickory, and cherry, chosen to suit pork and poultry. The Lumber Jack, Camp Chef, and Traeger blends use that same set of woods. Differences come from how the wood is processed and how consistent the pellets are.
Do pellets with fillers or binders matter?
Yes. Look for pellets labeled 100% hardwood. Fillers and flavor oils can leave more ash and change how the pellets burn. Brands such as Bear Mountain, Pit Boss, and Traeger state that they avoid fillers, flavorings, or binders.
How should I store wood pellets?
Keep them in a sealed container in a dry place. Damp pellets swell, crumble into sawdust, and jam the auger. Empty the hopper if the grill will sit for several days, especially in wet weather.
Can I mix different pellet flavors?
Yes. Many cooks mix a strong wood like hickory with a milder fruitwood. Run the hopper low before switching so you know which flavor is burning.
The Bottom Line
For most backyards, Lumber Jack Competition Blend is the one to buy. For beef, choose Bear Mountain Gourmet Blend, and for heavy use, the Pit Boss 40 lb bag saves refills. Add Lumber Jack 100% Hickory when you want a stronger smoke. Do the per-pound math, store the bag dry, and the flavor mostly takes care of itself.